Database Search Algorithms

Members of the American Association of Law Libraries (AALL) should check out Susan Nevelow Mart's presentation on Understanding the Human Element in Search Algorithms at AALL's annual conference and her article in the AALL Spectrum "Every Algorithm has a POV" (AALL Spectrum, Sept./Oct. 2017, v.22 Number 1, p.40). She compares the results of using WestlawNext, Lexis Advance, Fastcase, Google Scholar, Ravel and Casetext's search algorithms. Nevelow Mart emphasizes that the algorithms are designed by people, who must make decisions about how heavily to weigh date, word frequency, proximity, authoritativeness, etc. when they are designing the algorithms.

In order to search effectively, it helps to understand the broad outlines of how the algorithm for each database functions. Fastcase has responded to these concerns and is giving some control to the searcher. The Advanced Search in Fastcase 7 now allows the user to customize the relevance algorithm:

Changing the weight of choices like Search Relevance Score affects the search results. 

Take a look at whatever databases you have access to - Lexis Advance, WestlawNext, Fastcase, Google Scholar, etc. - and run the same "natural language" search in each.  Results may differ somewhat based upon the content that is available in each database, but chances are that if you see substantial differences in results, it is also tied to the relevance algorithm.


More from the blog

Are you working on a bankruptcy case and looking for a treatise that covers key bankruptcy law issues? If so, check out Ginsberg & Martin on Bankruptcy, 5th Edition . This treatise offers chapters on many areas of bankruptcy law, such as voluntary and involuntary petitions, automatic stay,...
Fastcase offers a research tool called Authority Check , which helps find later citing cases to a particular case. Authority Check can be used to locate related authority on your topic or to prioritize your research by looking for the most fequenty cited cases. In the Fastcase Classic interface,...
Fastcase * offers a great feature called Public Link . This tool provides a link that can be embedded in a memorandum or other document to quickly pull up a case. You don't have to be authenticated into Fastcase for the link to work. Once you have pulled up a case in Fastcase, look for the Public...