Blog

Finding Cases Related to a Court Rule

Researching a court rule and looking for cases? Shepardize or Keycite the rule. Take as an example PARCP 402 which deals with manner and acceptance of service. When you pull up this rule on Westlaw, you get over 1,000 citing references:

These citing references can then be filtered by cases, statutes, secondary material, etc. Within each category, additional filters appear - your options vary depending upon which type of material you are viewing. Cases, for example, allow you to filter by jurisdiction, date, reported status, keyword and more. Check out also the Notes of Decisions and Context and Analysis tabs, which provide the annotations from the annotated version of the rule in Purdon's.

Pull up the same rule in Lexis (also annotated) and select Shepardize this Document. Lexis easily allows you to focus on the citations by sub-part, as you can see from this snippet of the results break-down:

Be cautious when selecting the sub-part of interest.  Just because you are interested in 402(a), it doesn't mean there isn't also something relevant being discussed under 402. Once you have selected a sub-part, you may then filter by Citing Decisions and Other Citing Sources. Citing Decisions allows you to filter further by analysis, court, keyword or date.

Want more tips for finding cases related to court rules? Ask us!

 

More from the blog

Next week, on October 1, 2019, an order amending Chapter 1920 (Actions of Divorce or For Annulment of Marriage) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure will go into effect ( 49 Pa.B. 3059 ; June 15, 2019). The Domestic Relations Procedural Rules Committee recommended revisions to Rules 1920.14...
The PA Supreme Court has adopted a new rule , effective May 1, 2019 that allows parties to cite unpublished opinions in the intermediate appellate courts for persuasive authority. The provision to Rule 126 allows parties to rely on unpublished non-precedential memorandum decisions of the Superior...
The PA Supreme Court adopted new rules concerning custody that went into effect 3/1/2019. The new rules relate to parenting coordinators and open the possibility of a judicial district implementing a parenting coordination program. These programs incorporate the concept of mediation to assist in...